Silver Star Properties (SLVS) Hartman Shareholder Alliance Accuses Board of Value Destruction and Dodging Court-Ordered Annual Meeting
Value Destruction and Refusal to Hold Court-Ordered Annual Meeting
November 5, 2025
Dear Shareholder,
This letter provides information about Silver Star Properties that you deserve to know.
- Haddock's Promised “Distributions”
What Haddock Promised (October 31, 2024):
· Promised that Silver Star would "start distributions by the third quarter of 2025"
The Reality (One Year Later):
· No distributions made to shareholders (Q3 2025 came and went)
· Company value has declined further
- Haddock's "Crown Jewel" Lawsuit
What Haddock Promised (October 31, 2024):
· Called his lawsuit against Hartman a "crown jewel" worth "$50 million, $75 million, $100 million"
· Claimed lawsuit damages would benefit shareholders
The Reality (One Year Later):
· No benefit for shareholders.
· Instead, by spending money on meritless litigation, Haddock, Still, and Tompkins are wasting resources and damaging the company. Instead, by spending money on meritless litigation, Haddock, Still, and Tompkins are wasting resources and damaging the company. Silver Star’s meritless counterclaims were made in retaliation to straightforward claims against Silver Star for repayment of a loan Hartman made to the company. What Haddock calls the “crown jewel” is thus likely to be a net negative for the company.
- Southern Star - $30 Million Valuation Issue
In September 2024, Haddock estimated that Southern Star has a gross value of $30 million. It defies logic for Southern Star’s value to have increased tenfold from $3 to $30 million. Furthermore, Silver Star is currently being sued by the previous owner of Southern Star because he was never paid. Silver Star has not disclosed Southern Star’s lawsuit to shareholders.
- Occupancy Rate Collapse
Silver Star fired leasing and marketing staff and occupancy rates declined. We did an analysis of the last 6 legacy assets owned by Silver Star and found the following:
· Prior occupancy as of Q3 2022 across legacy portfolio below: 83%
· Current occupancy: 56.7%
· Property-by-property decline:
o Three Forest: 80% to 57%
o Westheimer: 80% to 55.7%
o 601 Sawyer: 85% to 58.8%
o The Preserve: 90% to 68.9%
o One Technology: 90% to 50%
o Cornerstone: 70% to 50%
- Fire-Sale Property Dispositions as Property Occupancy Rates Decline
As property occupancy rates declined, the values dropped 68%. The below information was derived from Silver Star’s proxy filing, and shows that as time went on and occupancy rates declined, property values dropped as low as 27% what they had them on the books for.
Sales Price Per Square Foot:
· 2023: $118/sq ft
· 1H 2024: $106/sq ft
· 2H 2024: $36/sq ft
· 1H 2025: $38/sq ft
· Decline: 68% drop in sale prices
- Soliciting Proxy Votes Without Audited Financial Statements
In May 2025, Silver Star told a Maryland court that the deadline for holding an annual meeting needed to be extended because it would be violating federal law if it solicited proxy votes without audited financial statements for fiscal years 2023 and 2024. After the Maryland court extended the deadline to October 21, 2025, Silver Star did not secure audited financial statements before soliciting proxy votes. Instead, Silver Star proceeded to solicit proxy votes without audited financial statements. Indeed, to this day, Silver Star still has not provided shareholders with audited financial statements for fiscal years 2023 and 2024 – Letter from SEC
- Six Annual Meeting Postponements
They are scared to death of having your voice heard.
Timeline:
· June 30, 2025 - Meeting postponed
· July 15, 2025 - Meeting postponed
· August 29, 2025 - Meeting postponed
· October 6, 2025 - Meeting postponed
· October 20, 2025 - Meeting postponed
· Current - Meeting postponed indefinitely
The courts have been clear. On October 16, 2025, the federal judge made it clear that no relief from the Maryland court’s October 21, 2025 deadline for Silver Star’s annual meeting was needed. When it set the October 21, 2025 deadline nearly four months ago, the Maryland State court said "No further extension will be granted."
- Discriminating Against Approximately 20% of Shareholders
In June 2025, management executed a 3:1 "flip-in" stock distribution that tripled certain shareholders' holdings — including management's own shares — while deliberately excluding approximately 20% of shareholders. We believe this “flip-in” distribution was impermissible.
When questioned why 20% were excluded, Haddock’s response was: “They are a part of the Hartman group. You can have your attorney call my attorney."
To create an unfair advantage for themselves in the proxy solicitation, Silver Star’s entrenched directors selectively decided who deserves additional shares to vote and who doesn't.
- Improperly Refusing Books and Records Requests
Despite our formal requests to receive books and records pursuant to Maryland law, and our multiple follow up requests, Silver Star’s entrenched directors have refused to provide updated shareholder lists, among other information. They have had updated information about shareholders to contact during the proxy solicitation, but the Hartman Group did not.
- Omitting Consent Revocations
In November 2023, Silver Star adopted a new bylaw permitting shareholder action by less than unanimous consent and initiated a written consent solicitation for, among other things, the election of directors. The only candidates listed for Silver Star’s consent solicitation were Haddock, Still, and Tompkins; there was no option or opportunity to nominate or vote for any other candidate.
Silver Star reported to the SEC that they received 51% shareholder support in their consent solicitation. What they concealed: We delivered consent revocations from holders of approximately 30% of outstanding shares. Thus, substantially less than 51% votes received supported Silver Star’s consent solicitation.
The pattern is clear:
· Destruction of shareholder value
· Refusal to hold court-ordered annual meeting
We demand that the entrenched directors immediately resign from the board for their improper oversight, poor judgment, and destruction of value. Call, email and text them today to demand their immediate resignation.
Gerald Haddock
Email: Gerald@haddockinvestments.com
Phone: 817-307-5146
Jim Still
Email: jim.still@rdcadvisors.com
Phone: 267-226-0241
Jack Tompkins
Email: jtompkins@artaequity.com
Phone: 713-817-3515
Thank you for your support.
Sincerely,
Al Hartman
The Hartman Shareholder Alliance
Source:
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/831616/000110465925107109/tm2530400d1_dfan14a.htm
Member discussion