Allen Hartman Calls for Haddock’s Removal Over Excessive Stock Grant at Silver Star Properties REIT (SLVS)

Market Cap: $23 million| Silver Star Properties REIT, Inc. is a self-managed real estate investment trust that is currently repositioning in an orderly manner into the self storage asset class.

• On October 17, 2023, Allen R. Hartman (15%) expressed his belief that Silver Star should pursue a liquidation strategy and return capital to investors due to perceived mismanagement. He argued that most stockholders would prefer their capital returned in a Texas commercial property REIT rather than risking it in a national self-storage strategy. Mr. Hartman attributed Silver Star's declining value to mismanagement by the Executive Committee, led by Gerald Haddock. He accused Silver Star of adopting a short-term liquidation approach with asset sales at discounted prices and overinvestment in self-storage ventures at high costs to investors. Silver Star hadn't held an annual stockholder meeting since 2013, leading Mr. Hartman to file a lawsuit for a 2023 meeting. In response, Silver Star changed its Bylaws to allow stockholders to act without a meeting, a move contested by Mr. Hartman as violating Maryland law. Additionally, he and vREIT requested access to Silver Star's stock ledger, which was denied, claiming a lack of a "legitimate purpose." Source
• On October 19, 2023, Mr. Hartman and vREIT filed a First Amended Complaint in the Maryland Litigation to compel a 2023 annual meeting, inspect the stock ledger, and declare the Purported Bylaw Amendment unlawful. Source
• On December 14, 2023, Allen R. Hartman issued a press release disclosing that he object to the ongoing consent solicitation and that he is going to vote “NO” to the proposal in the Consent Solicitation for the re-election of Jack I. Tompkins, Gerald W. Haddock and James S. Still to the Board.
• On December 14, 2023, Silver Star Properties REIT, Inc. initiated legal proceedings against Allen R. Hartman and related parties, alleging multiple charges including fraud, conspiracy, slander of title, and breach of contract. The company contends that the Hartman Defendants engaged in self-dealing, misused company resources, breached fiduciary duties, and conducted fraudulent litigation, resulting in substantial damages. These legal actions seek to address the alleged misconduct and facilitate the recovery of damages. Source
• On January 8, 2024, Silver Star Properties REIT, Inc. stated that it is conducting a Consent Solicitation to re-elect incumbent directors while seeking to reduce the board's size, effectively removing Allen Hartman. Hartman, the largest stockholder, strongly opposes the re-election, alleging that the board is avoiding an annual meeting, violating the company's charter, and preventing meaningful stockholder choices. Source
• On January 12, 2024, Allen Hartman and the Hartman Group sent an email to the shareholders, expressing frustration with the current Board and advocating for the liquidation of the company instead of pursuing a self-storage strategy. They proposed a new board focused on selling properties, paying down debt, and returning capital to shareholders. They cited an estimated conservative value of $8.00 per share and urged investors to revoke their consent solicitation votes to push for liquidation. Source
• On January 18, 2024, Allen Hartman and the Hartman Group sent a letter to the shareholders countering Haddock's (CEO of the company)claims and the ongoing Consent Solicitation. Hartman denied using the company for personal gain, unlike Haddock, who took fees and awarded himself convertible units. He criticized Haddock's lack of experience and mismanagement, leading to poor company performance and auditor issues. Hartman emphasized the need for liquidation as per the company's charter, opposing the Board's new strategy. He called for a shareholder meeting to decide on asset sales and capital return, urging shareholders to revoke consent to the Board's current plans.
• On March 21, 2025, Allen R. Hartman (7.9%) delivered a letter to the company nominating a slate of three director candidates, Allen R. Hartman, Brent Longnecker and Benjamin Thomas, for election to the board at the 2025 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. Source
• On April 1, 2025, the Hartman Group issued a letter to the shareholders criticizing Silver Star Properties’ leadership under Haddock, blaming them for destroying $278 million in net asset value since 2022 through their failed "New Direction Plan." They disputed SSP’s financial claims, highlighted past tenant satisfaction, and accused management of poor asset sales, mismanagement, and excessive compensation. The letter referenced a court order requiring a shareholder vote within six months to choose between liquidation and an alternative strategy, urging shareholders to consider replacing the board and holding management accountable.
• On April 10, 2025, Al Hartman issued a letter to Silver Star shareholders condemning CEO Gerald Haddock’s award of 1 million shares to himself, calling it excessive and lacking endorsement from reputable compensation experts. Hartman said he spoke with 35 major shareholders representing nearly 20% of shares—97% of whom want Haddock removed. He accused Haddock of breaching fiduciary duty and prioritizing self-enrichment despite the company’s poor performance, suggesting legal action may follow his removal.